These 9 Blue Nile Earrings Go With Literally Everything

If you're building a jewelry collection that truly works for your everyday life, you know how important it is to find pieces that go with everything. Versatility is key when it comes to jewelry pieces you’ll actually reach for, and Blue Nile earrings are some of the most wearable, elegant, and reliable picks out there.

Whether you're dressing for a casual coffee run or slipping into something sleek for a night out, these nine Blue Nile earrings will fit the moment. We’re talking sparkle, color, and personality all in styles you’ll wear on repeat. The best part? These pieces are crafted with quality in mind, so you're not just adding pretty accessories, you’re investing in timeless staples.

Here are 9 Blue Nile earrings that go with literally everything:

1. Four-Prong Round Brilliant Lab-Grown Diamond Stud Earrings

Image Source: Blue Nile

Shop $910 $637

Diamond studs are basically the little black dress of jewelry. These lab-grown versions deliver the same fire and brilliance with a modern, eco-conscious twist. Set in 14k white gold and crafted to catch light from every angle, they’re the kind of earrings you never need to take off day or night. They also make an amazing gift for anyone who prefers something subtle yet luxurious.

2. Sapphire Stud Earrings in 18k White Gold

Image Source: Blue Nile

Shop $1,220 $976

Sapphire studs add just the right pop of color while still feeling polished and grown-up. This 5mm pair in white gold pairs just as easily with a tee and jeans as it does with a sleek black dress. Their deep blue color brings a timeless vibe, giving your outfit a polished feel without screaming for attention.

3. Round Ruby and Diamond Hoop Earrings

Image Source: Blue Nile

Shop $1,770 $1,416

A twist on a classic hoop, this ruby and diamond combo adds a hint of boldness to your look. The half-inch size makes them noticeable but not overwhelming—ideal for everyday sparkle with a side of confidence. These are especially great when you want something with a little drama, but not full-on statement.

4. Lab-Grown Diamond Love Knot Stud Earrings

Image Source: Blue Nile

Shop $1,270 $1,016

If you like jewelry with symbolism, love knots are for you. These lab-grown diamond earrings are modern and meaningful with a touch of contrast thanks to the yellow and black gold setting. They’re chic, thoughtful, and wearable in any setting from work meetings to weekend brunch. Plus, the mixed-metal look pairs well with both silver and gold accessories.

5. Diamond Halo Composite Earrings in 14k White Gold

Image Source: Blue Nile

Shop $1,520 $1,064

A halo setting always amplifies sparkle, and these composite diamond earrings prove it. Their dainty size makes them everyday-friendly, but the design brings serious elegance. Think: Zoom call to dinner date without changing your jewelry. They’re the perfect pick for that elevated feel without being too flashy.

6. Oval Sapphire and Diamond Micropavé Stud Earrings

Image Source: Blue Nile

Shop $2,120 $1,484

These oval sapphire studs with micropavé diamonds are classic with a twist. They feel luxe but wearable, adding subtle drama to both daytime and evening looks. Whether you’re heading into a big meeting or out for cocktails, they strike the perfect balance between refined and bold.

7. Lab-Grown Diamond Pear Halo Dangle Earrings

Image Source: Blue Nile

Shop $3,140 $2,198

Want something that turns heads? These pear-shaped halo dangles are showstoppers. Even though they’re statement-making, they’re refined enough to wear with a white button-up and jeans—or your favorite wedding guest dress. The movement catches the light beautifully, making them an easy way to elevate even the simplest look.

8. Amethyst Fashion Petal Drop Earrings

Image Source: Blue Nile

Shop $390 $273

Floral-inspired and playful, these amethyst petal earrings are perfect for adding a little color and fun to your everyday rotation. The sterling silver makes them light and easy to wear all day. The soft purple tone adds femininity, and the unique design makes them feel like wearable art.

9. Pear-Shaped London Blue Topaz Drop Earrings

Image Source: Blue Nile

Shop $270 $202

The deep tone of London Blue Topaz makes these earrings feel both serene and sophisticated. They're polished enough for the office, but still fun for a night out. The cool hue complements neutrals, pastels, and bold shades—making them one of the most versatile gemstone picks you can wear all year long.

Whether you’re looking to build your everyday jewelry lineup or simply treat yourself to something you’ll wear again and again, these 9 Blue Nile earrings check every box: beautiful, versatile, and effortlessly wearable. Don’t be surprised if you end up wearing them every single day. From work to weekend, these pieces are meant to move with you and make you feel polished without even trying.

FAQs

1. Is Blue Nile jewelry legitimate?

Yes, Blue Nile is a well-known and trusted name in fine jewelry. They offer GIA-certified diamonds and high-quality gemstones with transparent pricing. Their pieces are crafted with attention to detail and considered one of the pioneers of online luxury jewelry shopping.

2. Can you return Blue Nile jewelry?

Absolutely. Blue Nile has a 30-day return policy, allowing you to return items for a full refund or exchange if they’re not quite right. Returns are free and hassle-free, making it easy to shop confidently.

3. What is the Blue Nile lifetime guarantee?

Blue Nile offers a lifetime manufacturer's warranty on all fine jewelry. This covers any defects in materials or craftsmanship, but not normal wear and tear. They also offer complimentary cleaning and inspection services.

READ MORE: Why Fashion Lovers Are Raving About Flat Back Earrings